Now Open! New Event Room now open! View Our Menu

Taste Excellence

Fireside Cafe is a cozy fast-casual restaurant located inside Yoder's Shopping Center in Shipshewana. Our menu features applewood slow-smoked meats and beans and a variety of made-from-scratch recipes. Come on in, order at the counter, and sip your drinks while we bring the food out to your table. Experience Fireside Cafe!

Fireside Features


  • Your Location or Ours?


    A variety of catering options are available for

    - Weddings
    - Graduation Parties
    - Family Reunions
    - Class Reunions
    - Parties of any size!



    Have your event for up to 100 people at Fireside Cafe!
    - Rehearsal Dinners
    - Holiday Parties
    - Lunch or Dinner Meetings

Burgers & Waffle Fries

You asked for them, and here they are!  
Half pound Angus burgers on brioche buns, served with waffle fries!

  • Smokehouse Burger

    Topped with Cheese, Pulled Pork, BBQ Sauce,
    Red Onions, and Sweet & Spicy Pickles

  • Deluxe Bacon Cheeseburger

    Topped with Cheese, Bacon, Red Onions,
    Lettuce, and Sweet & Spicy Pickles

  • Cheeseburger

    Simple yet delicious!  
    An amazing burger topped with cheese!

Jams & Jellies

Great for gifts and sourvenirs!

Come in to sample our locally made jams & jellies.



    Favorites & Featured Ice Cream

    Fireside's Super Premium Ice Cream is always a treat! 

    • Exhausted Parent

      Bourbon-spiked espresso ice cream swirled with bittersweet chocolate chunks.

    • Banana Cream Pie

      Your favorite comfort food now on a cone! Banana ice cream churned with a marshmallow ripple and real Nilla Wafers.

    • Coming Soon - Caramel Apple Pie

      Spicy cinnamon ice cream mixed with chunks of real apples, crispy cinnamon shortbread pieces and a thick caramel ripple.

    • Coming Soon - Snap-O-Lantern

      An award-winning combination of spicy pumpkin-flavored ice cream and heaps of gingersnap cookies to partner the cooling autumn weather.