Fireside Cafe is a cozy fast-casual restaurant located inside Yoder's Shopping Center in Shipshewana. Our menu features applewood slow-smoked meats and beans and a variety of made-from-scratch recipes.
Come on in, order at the counter, and sip your drinks while we bring the food out to your table. Experience Fireside Cafe!
Your Location or Ours?
A variety of catering options are available for
- Graduation Parties
- Family Reunions
- Class Reunions
- Parties of any size!
Have your event for up to 100 people at Fireside Cafe!
- Rehearsal Dinners
- Holiday Parties
- Lunch or Dinner Meetings
Burgers & Waffle Fries
You asked for them, and here they are!
Half pound Angus burgers on brioche buns, served with waffle fries!
Topped with Cheese, Pulled Pork, BBQ Sauce,
Red Onions, and Sweet & Spicy Pickles
Deluxe Bacon Cheeseburger
Topped with Cheese, Bacon, Red Onions,
Lettuce, and Sweet & Spicy Pickles
Simple yet delicious!
An amazing burger topped with cheese!
Jams & Jellies
Great for gifts and sourvenirs!
Come in to sample our locally made jams & jellies.
Favorites & Featured Ice Cream
Fireside's Super Premium Ice Cream is always a treat!
Bourbon-spiked espresso ice cream swirled with bittersweet chocolate chunks.
Banana Cream Pie
Your favorite comfort food now on a cone! Banana ice cream churned with a marshmallow ripple and real Nilla Wafers.
Coming Soon - Caramel Apple Pie
Spicy cinnamon ice cream mixed with chunks of real apples, crispy cinnamon shortbread pieces and a thick caramel ripple.
Coming Soon - Snap-O-Lantern
An award-winning combination of spicy pumpkin-flavored ice cream and heaps of gingersnap cookies to partner the cooling autumn weather.
"One of the best places to get ice cream in Shipshewana!"
"The chopped brisket sandwich comes on a moist and yummy ciabatta bun. The meat is smoked (in house!) to perfection and I love that they hold the sauce so you can choose your own. My favorite is the sweet, though the original comes in a very close second."
"Just went there for lunch. If you're visiting or live in Shipshewana you must try this place. Great food and extremely friendly and helpful staff!"
"Their coffee and three little pigs breakfast burrito are so delicious!! I can't wait to try more! :)"