Fireside Cafe is a cozy fast-casual restaurant located inside Yoder's Shopping Center in Shipshewana. Our menu features applewood slow-smoked meats and beans and a variety of made-from-scratch recipes.
Come on in, order at the counter, and sip your drinks while we bring the food out to your table. Experience Fireside Cafe!
These items may be around for only a limited time!
Tuesday & Wednesday, Friday & Saturday after 4:00pm, until they're gone!
Prime RibOur Prime Rib is smoked in-house and served with Homemade Mashed Potatoes & Gravy, Rustic Baguette & Butter. 15.99
Make it a meal to add your choice of a Homemade Side, Large Fountain Drink, and Single Scoop of Super Premium Ice Cream. 18.99
Specialty Ice Cream & Desserts
Gourmet Waffle Crisp
This fun, new frozen dessert is a chocolate waffle cone wedge topped with caramel or fudge, dipped in chocolate, and loaded with toppings
Fireside Signature SundaeYour choice of three scoops of super premium ice cream, topped with a homemade cookie, a Waffle Crisp, hot fudge, whipped cream, nuts, and a cherry. All layered in a souvenir mug that is yours to keep!
Fireside 5 Scoop SundaeThat's right! Five scoops of Super Premium Ice Cream topped with a homemade cookie, whipped cream, nuts, and a cherry! We dare you to eat this on your own, but we won't blame you for sharing!
"One of the best places to get ice cream in Shipshewana!"
"The chopped brisket sandwich comes on a moist and yummy ciabatta bun. The meat is smoked (in house!) to perfection and I love that they hold the sauce so you can choose your own. My favorite is the sweet, though the original comes in a very close second."
"Just went there for lunch. If you're visiting or live in Shipshewana you must try this place. Great food and extremely friendly and helpful staff!"
"Their coffee and three little pigs breakfast burrito are so delicious!! I can't wait to try more! :)"